Dear Non-knitters who love a Knitter,
Today is the first of December, and I think it's probably pretty inevitable that you've heard from someone by now that Christmas is coming. (Pro-tip: They have scheduled it on the same day as last year. I think it's pretty consistent.) While regular people are about to have a very busy month, Knitters are under a special and unique strain. They have to do everything that regular people do, and in addition, they are undoubtedly knitting one or more items as gifts for Christmas, maybe for you. They are going to need special love and attention for the upcoming month, and we can talk about that more later, but for now, this is all you need to know. The knitting all-nighters, the frequent trips to the yarn store, the desperation and sobbing when the last darning needle is gone, the way that at least once in the next month they're going to yell "ARE YOU OUT OF YOUR MIND WHY WOULD I WANT TO GO TO A MOVIE WITH YOU I CAN'T CABLE IN THE DARK YOU ARE SO INSENSITIVE" is about to start for you and your knitter. (If you know or are related to more than one holiday gift knitter, you may want to connect with others in the comments so that you can form a support group. Multiple knitter contact in December can be emotionally difficult.)
Some of you may believe that it's the knitters choice about whether or not he or she does this to themselves every year, but it isn't. For many knitters who suffer from this variant, there is no choice. Sure as a nightingale has to sing, a gift knitter must knit - and the opportunity to knit a gift is - to your knitter, a chance to make the love that they feel in their hearts tangible, visible and warm. No matter how it looks (and we admit, it is difficult to see the love when a hat knitter is using filthy language to describe Aunt Alice's head size at 3am) gift knitting is a powerful and meaningful expression of human affection. Each stitch contains the most precious thing a knitter can give - time and talent, and every person who receives said gift of time and talent should be nothing short of stunned with joy and gratitude. Think about it. Other people are going to spend 20 minutes at the mall picking out a present for you. Your knitter loves you so much that their gift to you took hours and hours and hours of time that nobody else deserved.
Now, if you're normal, right now, my dear Non-knitter who loves a knitter, you're feeling pressured. You're thinking "Holy mittens, what the heck do you give someone for Christmas when they're going to give you something that amazing?" and dear non-knitter, I'm here for you. I know you love your knitter, and I know you know your knitter loves knitting, and I know that in the past, you've thought about buying some knitter stuff for them for Christmas, but it was all too much and then you bought that sweater for them instead and you think they liked it, because it was wool - and knitters like wool, right? You betcha, but let's move on. Over the next 25 days, I'm going to try and make some suggestions about stuff that knitters like that would make good presents.
Remember though, that knitters, while they have a lot in common, are also really unique. Follow your gut, do the recommended detective work, and follow these rules:
1. If your knitter has a lot of something (bags, yarn, magazines) this is because THEY LIKE THEM A LOT. I know that you would think that if someone has a lot of yarn that they wouldn't want more as a present, but you would be wrong. Having a lot of something means that your knitter enjoys that thing. It is a good thing to buy.
2. About that sweater that you bought? You were so close. The only thing you need to know is that knitters like sweaters, hats, scarves, mittens... but they like them to come "some assembly required." Pattern and yarn is a better idea than finished item.
3. Most knitters stashes are arranged in chronological layers, like in archeology. If you go into the stash to see what they like, remember that the newest stuff (the stuff that your knitter is into right now) will be on the top or "canopy" of the stash. Things deeper down are less reliable, and if you go deep enough to find mint green chunky brushed mohair? Give up. You've hit the 80's.
Let's begin.
Gifts for knitters, Day One:
Today's suggestion is knitting paper goods. Note cards, tags... knitters usually like knitters specific stuff, and they usually know other knitters that they would like to share this stuff with. These are some of my very favourites, but if you don't like what I like, try googling "Knitting stationary" "knitting cards" or "Knitting notes." Etsy (a place where you can buy handmade stuff in a variety of online shops) is a really good place to look. Knitters make handmade stuff, they appreciate the stuff other people make too.
Is your knitter super classy? Does she send thank you notes? Write letters? She might love these beautiful embossed knitting notes from Papersheep press.
Tilly Flop makes classic, wonderful knitting notes that I adore. Right now my favourite is "Keep calm and cast on"
Finally, and this is a good one if your knitter is a bit of a smartarse, Kniterella.
I have a special fondness for the notecards that say stuff like "If Knitting is wrong I don't want to be right", and I love the gift tags, that say things like "Just because it's handmade, doesn't mean it was cheap"
Good hunting, and if it seems to you like this isn't right for your knitter, don't panic. I've got 24 more ideas coming your way. Hang in there, and don't panic.
PS. In case you're wondering, nobody paid me to promote their products. This is just stuff I like.
PPS. For the knitters: I may have had a small yarn accident last night. 
I have a plan though.
PPPS: For the Non-knitters. See that? I have yarn, but I still bought more.
Love this! I am always met with the amazed look when more yarn/fibre enters the house..."But, you already have some!?!"
The cards are fantastic!
Posted by: blogless grace at December 1, 2011 11:13 AMToo funny! I read it to my non-knitter boyfriend and, having loved a crazy yarn lady for long enough to know, he found it really funny. If one of your suggestions is something I like I'll be sure to direct him back in this direction, though I suspect my Christmas gift this year is probably a ticket to Las Vegas.
Posted by: Angie at December 1, 2011 11:18 AMGood suggestions all, Steph! But I must add that paper gifts for knitters should include gift cards to yarn shops. Non-knitters, look at the labels on all the yarnshop bags stashed around your knitter's house. That's how you'll know where to buy the card.
Yarn accident! Love it.
Finally someone has summed it up perfectly! Forwarding this to my knit-receiving husband right now! Also looking forward to 24 posts in a row :) Happy knitting!
Posted by: Joelle at December 1, 2011 11:24 AMYou = Amazing.
Posted by: JennyB at December 1, 2011 11:24 AMOooh, pretty yarn! Now I'm curious - is it all for the same project? And if so, where can I find the pattern?
(Thank you, by the way, for the link to the "Oh, Deer!" mittens. I am into colorwork this season, apparently, and that pattern is now on my computer, waiting for the right yarn to present itself.)
I agree about the gift cards to a lys. My family doesn't get it, although I do enjoy the scented candles they buy me as well.
Posted by: LisaDinPA at December 1, 2011 11:27 AMFor years I have been giving this advice: Go to a yarn shop, touch and feel everything. Then pick something YOU like, in a color you like. You may then receive it back in gift form! It's a win-win!
Posted by: kashurst at December 1, 2011 11:28 AMI am, as usual, forwarding a link to this blog to my husband. Over 15 years of marriage, he has come to a closer understanding of what yarn means to me. He even has his own account at Halcyon Yarn so he can order things secretly. My swift and ball winder came from him as well as my niddy-noddy and a really exquisite skein of lace weight cashmere. But he still doesn't understand exactly how high "high stash" can mean. She who dies with the most yarn wins, right? xo
Posted by: Mim Bird at December 1, 2011 11:28 AMShoot. You posted too soon. Rams and I were trying to figure out in yesterday's comments how exactly you were committing all seven of the Deadly Sins in the Fernfrost post. With Fr. Mark's help, we had it almost figured out -- but I was hoping for a little more time this morning.
For the record, Rams, Steph had all seven, because she was mad about giving the scarf away. That's Wrath, and that's a sweep.
Posted by: Presbytera at December 1, 2011 11:34 AMNice post, I really liked it and will be forwarding it to DH.
As for the yarn accident, it wouldn't be more clogs would it?
Posted by: Cynthia K. at December 1, 2011 11:40 AM#1 on my list this year is a new knitting chair. Thanks for this list though; I'll post this on the fridge.
Posted by: JoAnn at December 1, 2011 11:42 AMMy favorite Kniterella is "Yes, I did make it and no, you can't return it." I just haven't had the nerve to actually attach it to a gift.
Posted by: Julie McC at December 1, 2011 11:43 AMThis is so brilliant, I just forwarded it to my husband!
Posted by: themaidenmetallurgist at December 1, 2011 11:45 AMHow happy am I that I know my hubby reads your blog? Do you think he'll take the hint? Yay me!
Posted by: Christine at December 1, 2011 11:45 AMExcellent post. My brother is always astounded that I could possibly want more yarn...maybe this can help him understand. I also especially like the part about looking at the top of the stash for advice on what kinds of things to buy. Great and witty advice.
Posted by: Cassy at December 1, 2011 11:52 AMThis. Is. Classic.
Posted by: Rayna at December 1, 2011 11:53 AMPerfect summation! This is the year, by golly, that I print out the post and hang it on my fridge. Hubby already bought me a yarn club membership (I may or may not have arranged and paid for it myself and informed him after the fact) but there are still two sons who may wish to read your helpful hints!
Merry Christmas, Stephanie! (psssst: and try to stick to your plan!)
Posted by: cherie at December 1, 2011 11:55 AMTo add extra insanity, plan to spin your own yarn for the projects needed by Dec. 25. Love the blog. I look forward to every post.
Posted by: Heather at December 1, 2011 11:56 AMI was thinking it's a clog thing, but that yarn doesn't look bulky enough to be something that big, esp. if you are knitting it for you-know-who-mas.
Is it a mitten thing?
Posted by: Ed at December 1, 2011 12:03 PMThank you for this! I have forwarded this to the appropriate members of my family. And I am grateful that this came out early enough to prevent any serious damage to our familial relationships ...
Posted by: Sage at December 1, 2011 12:06 PMI had to comment! I read your blog regularly, and love it, and love the laughs (which is a wonderful gift you give to us, btw) Any way. I want to forward this to so many people. Who knew there were tags about how "yes,your gift is handmade and it is not cheap." I needed this last time I made my mother something, and she complained about it (felted slippers).(yes, I still love her and no, I don't knit things for her anymore). Great blog post!
Laurie
Thank you for helping me realize that my sudden urge to knit my brother an afghan for the holidays is not insanity but knitterly affection!
And I am going to send this to my husband right away as he's been asking for gift ideas. He's feeling especially fond of you at the moment thanks to the lovely big bowl of veggie soup he had for dinner last night...
Posted by: Dorie at December 1, 2011 12:11 PMJust made my non-knitting DH listen attentively (under pain of no dinner) to your words of wisdom ...
He didn't fidget, he didn't yawn and I swear I saw a small twitch at the corner of his mouth which may have been signifying pleasure or amusement - both are good things.
He has promised to be in attendance same time tomorrow and will be sitting comfortably
x
Classic post that is going up on my fridge!
Thank you so much!
However, I do feel the need to correct one tiny thing... That isn't an "accident." According to a friend who also happens to be an Emergency Department nurse tells me an "accident" is something that is "unexpected and a complete surprise." An "incident" is an occurrence of something that is bound to happen... For instance.. put a drunk driver behind a wheel and you would expect that there would be a crash.. It's an "incident", someone skiing down a mountain on two planks of wood crashes.. it's an incident
you (or me) going into a yarn store.. and coming out with some yarn.. expected.. incident...
Posted by: sheila at December 1, 2011 12:20 PMThank you, this was just the pick-me-up I needed for my day. So funny and so true! Can't wait to see what your plan is. Love the yarn!
Posted by: ErinE at December 1, 2011 12:20 PMThis is going to be forwarded so many times.... Pitch perfect.
Posted by: Christine at December 1, 2011 12:22 PMThis made me laugh so much. It's so spot on! Instead of yelling about movies though, I've yelled if people expected me to drive somewhere instead of letting me be the knitting passenger.
Love that you're doing gift ideas. Can't wait to read them all and forward to the appropriate people.
Posted by: Mary at December 1, 2011 12:22 PMYou really do crack me up! Can't wait to share this with my husband.
Posted by: Beth at December 1, 2011 12:23 PMYay! I love these posts for Christmas, they're some of my favorite posts, Stephanie! Thank you!
I always forward them to anyone who may be thinking about giving me a Christmas gift. :)
Posted by: Brooketopia at December 1, 2011 12:24 PMAre you going to ask Lene for a schedule this year?
Posted by: Leta at December 1, 2011 12:26 PMI am forwarding this to a lot of people. One question. Is it ok to throw a ball a yarn at someone when they say "Don't you have enough yarn?" or "Why do you need anymore yarn?"
Posted by: Barb at December 1, 2011 12:32 PMOh, pooh. Papersheep is out of that card. Plead with them to make more - soon. Love Fernfrost although in photos it's gone from pinkish, to golden to white. And the antlers in the mittens - to die for!!
Posted by: lynne at December 1, 2011 12:33 PMI'm sorry Stephanie, but we need Knitting Stationery (not stationary, although generally we are not moving a lot while knitting. Some of us walk or may be in a moving vehicle, of course.), and "really unique" is .... well, too much. Unique is unique. Unique doesn't get a modifier.
But yeah, excellent suggestions. I'm sending this to my husband and children.
Posted by: Hilary at December 1, 2011 12:34 PMOh, you are so great, the top section of your post made me tear up, as I sit here in my office (where I work full time writing and typing all day) icing my hands and wrists from trying to get socks done for all my special Guys this Christmas- knitting like crazy at night in between dinner and laundry. Like all of us this time of year! So much love to express in wool... so little room in our wrists for swollen tendons. :) Thank you for the support for our non-knitting loved ones, who are trying to feel the love as the twitches develop over our eyes!
Posted by: Val at December 1, 2011 12:40 PMOooo! Look at all that pretty Cascade! I'm wondering if your plan is colorwork? Or lots of hats for your loved ones....
Posted by: Dianne at December 1, 2011 12:45 PMMy knitting daughter needs to include this post with every knitty gift she gives this year!
Posted by: Mom of a Knit-a-holic at December 1, 2011 12:45 PMI spy with my little eye some yarn for a Jayne hat? :D
Posted by: Leah at December 1, 2011 12:54 PMlove it all... You are so right.. more is not just more.. more is great! look forward to the next 24.
Posted by: lydia at December 1, 2011 12:55 PMLOL Besides what is a definition of too much yarn.
Posted by: Cookie at December 1, 2011 1:09 PMI needed this post years ago: third-person verification for when a certain in-law told me that if she'd known I already had yarn she might not have bought me that other. Her husband roared with laughter: "I bet you don't know the half of it, dear."
Yes but. When I knitted with what she bought me (at my request after she asked for suggestions) I felt love and gratitude for her as well as the person I was knitting for. So there.
Posted by: AlisonH at December 1, 2011 1:14 PMLast Christmas my husband put three skeins of sock yarn in my stocking. We've only been married 37 years and he's trained already!
Posted by: doreen at December 1, 2011 1:17 PMLOL...yarn accident! Last night I had a swift and ball winder accident. Came home, handed them to my hubby and said, that is exactly what I wanted for Christmas, wrap it up! LOL...that is how I get it done here otherwise I end up with crazy arse gifts. ;-)
Posted by: Michele at December 1, 2011 1:20 PMThis just made my day. I, a knitter, am so going to send this to my husband who never knows what to get me :) thank you!
Posted by: Telma costa at December 1, 2011 1:26 PMPerfectly explains the gift knitter to the muggles. Excellent. Looking forward to the rest of the days' suggestions. If anyone knows a physicist who can bend time and space, I think a perfect gift for a knitter would be a TARDIS. Or even just a portal from the living room into the LYS.
Posted by: whirlybird at December 1, 2011 1:27 PMI edit/copy edit pasted this into an email for my family..... all of them including the 3 children...
thank you.. very helpful....
Sara
Posted by: sara at December 1, 2011 1:28 PMi am amazed that after 3 years reading your blog, you can still crack me the fuck up. thanks for so many smiles ms. mcphee.
Posted by: steven a. at December 1, 2011 1:34 PMWhen u start the support group, let me know. i am married to a gift knitter
Posted by: Mike at December 1, 2011 1:36 PMDear Stephanie,
You did not have a 'yarn accident' last night. You had a 'yarn orgy' - or if we would wish to be a bit more ladylike a 'yarn celebration'. Carry on! Post pictures of what you do with it.
this is an excellent public service. thank you
Posted by: stacia potter at December 1, 2011 1:41 PMA double knitted rainbow? Can't wait to see new project.
Posted by: Kelly at December 1, 2011 1:47 PMOooh pretty yarns! Can't wait to see what they become!
I may be one of the few knitters who doesn't like receiving gift yarn from Muggles. It tends to be a fiber or weight I'm not terribly keen on, and then I feel guilty not knitting it, or knit it and don't enjoy it and feel like I'm wasting my time. But I'm not quite as clever as you are--you can probably come up with something brilliant no matter what yarn you start with!
LOVE the knitting stationery. The "yo" card from tillyflop is so clever!
Posted by: ashpags at December 1, 2011 2:04 PMMy husband and I hunt together (economic and relationship reasons. Please don't flame me. :o) ) and deer season started this week. Anyway, here's his response: "Yep...that's you, alright. But if you feel conflicted between deer hunting and knitting, just remember that I have several good venison recipes but none so far for fricassee of mitten."
Posted by: Karen in Kansas at December 1, 2011 2:06 PMAlso a thing (well, two) to think about when it comes to yarn.
1. If your knitter is doing a "stash diet" that means that she is actually desperate for more yarn, but she cannot buy it herself because she is on a diet. Gift yarn is even more appreciated than normal.
2. Know where your knitter shops. Chances are they will know what items your knitter has been petting and then regretfully putting away. Those are wonderful gifts whether they are books, magazines, yarn, or accessories.
Posted by: Seanna Lea at December 1, 2011 2:09 PMJulie McC at 11:43 - I think my response would be "Yes, you can return it to me but don't expect to get anything else (ever again)".
The "yarn accident/incident" looks like Fairisle and a hap shawl to me.
Posted by: =Tamar at December 1, 2011 2:12 PMYes! more yarn! The optimist in my celebrates with you!
Posted by: Naomi at December 1, 2011 2:17 PMLove, love, love this post! I am printing it out and sticking it on my fridge for some serious hinting to my family.
I laughed hard at "the top or 'canopy' of the stash".
Thank you for helping our friends and family choose gifts that knitters will love!
It would behoove the blog reader to PRINT OUT the Harlot this month and, you know, leave it lying around for the non-knitter who might be having breakfast or lounging near the coffee table. Some deft highlighting will draw the eye (Hmm, what's this important document?) of the non-knitting will-be gifter.
And hey, where's your pics of the finished Gwendolyn? I'm making one too and need to see that it can be done. When you've got a sec. ;)
Posted by: Melissa-Louise at December 1, 2011 2:19 PMLOVE the new yarn. No wonder you had an accident. And your comment about hitting the 80's, almost made me spit up my tea! Too funny.
Posted by: wendy at December 1, 2011 2:21 PMHaving been the recipient of a well-intentioned (but total miss) gift of yarn and pattern (more than once), thank you for this post. I've already instructed my favorited knitting recipient to read it and take notes.
Posted by: Cathy at December 1, 2011 2:21 PMSo I copied a link to your blog, and then sent this to my husband, who has been bugging me about (a) my most recent LYS debacle and (b) christmas present ideas:
Honey -
This may help you understand me a little bit more. Every little bit helps, as you know.
http://www.yarnharlot.ca/blog/\
And if you find a guy that blogs about expensive watch cases & driving fast, I’d be interested in reading that in an attempt to understand YOU better, too.
Ooh fun! I will say that the best present I ever got from my brother was a whole heap of alpaca yarn with the accompanying threat that he would beat me up if I made something for someone else out of it. It is now the Kimono Shawl from the Folk Shawls book. He rocks, that brother, even though I know he really may have done some damage if I hadn't followed his directive!
Gillian
ps You can let folks know about the woven "knitted by ___" I have a heap and love them. They help folks tell the back from the front of a sweater...
Posted by: Gillian at December 1, 2011 2:35 PMExcept for the brown, that yarn looks suspiciously like the colors I've been amassing (so far Kalamazoo and Manhattan have contributed -- and I'd still like a lavender.) Would I be right in believing you've done a test run of a matching hat lately?
Thanks for this! Like so many others, I've sent this to my husband and my dad (mom's also a knitter). They're both hopeless, but maybe this year they'll get it right. When's your post about cashmere??!?
Posted by: krystina at December 1, 2011 2:38 PMGreat colors!
Posted by: Kimberly at December 1, 2011 2:43 PMIf I send you my number, would you mind telling my honey that I really NEED a drum carder?
Posted by: Jen in WI at December 1, 2011 2:57 PMI laughed so hard at "some assembly required." I think every pattern should include those words!
Posted by: Alyssa at December 1, 2011 3:14 PMIt amazes me when people say I am hard to buy for. Avid knitters always have lots of gift options! Your ideas are great, and I am looking forward to the other 24!
Posted by: Sally, California at December 1, 2011 3:19 PMCould we get the license plate of the yarn bus that hit you? It looked seriously and beautifully loaded!
Posted by: Catherine at December 1, 2011 3:21 PMJust love it! I'd like some of those knitting quotes as fridge magnets. Off to google, I think....
Posted by: Perpetua at December 1, 2011 3:25 PMTHANK YOU for the gifts for knitters countdown! What a brilliant idea! I am glad I am not the only one that has knitting incidents...also, I love getting yarn, but hate getting one skein, because inevitably, that one skein will be the only one in the universe w/ like, 40 yards on it! Uhm thanks for thinking of me, what the heck do I do with the smallest amount of yarn EVER! I already have like 400 coasters...
Posted by: sweetpeajenny at December 1, 2011 3:25 PMHoly Sheep! That's not a "small" yarn accident! That's not all for Christmas knitting, I hope?? Please tell us it's for something to unwind with once the Christmas knitting is done.
Posted by: Elizabeth at December 1, 2011 3:27 PMDon't take this wrong, but...I love you Stephanie Pearl-McPhee.
Posted by: Betty at December 1, 2011 3:40 PMOh My! i LOVED this post. The biggest grin in days!
What a wonderful idea.
Unique can too have a modifier! Even if people disagree, jeez. Not a big deal.
I looove how you ended this post. You're hilarious!
Posted by: twelvedaysold at December 1, 2011 3:45 PMThanks for this list! I love this and all of your posts, but I have a random question that I meant to ask you on random Monday. I was just re-reading 'Free-Range Knitter' because I had finished your latest book and came across the story describing the reverse-engineering fiasco of the baby bonnet. Would you mind posting or emailing the name of the book that the baby bonnet pattern is in. The bonnet sounds adorable and I have some new friends' babies coming into my life. Thanks.
Posted by: Penelope at December 1, 2011 3:54 PMthis is great, but your description of the stash layers & the "canopy" was especially spot-on. i read it in a pointed way to my boyfriend just now... we'll see what results.
Posted by: juniperjune at December 1, 2011 3:54 PMIs it wrong that I want to subscribe every so in my life to this blog for the next 24 days?
Posted by: jennifer at December 1, 2011 3:55 PMTHANK YOU. For all your writing and especially for today. I thought I was ahead. I picked out the patterns, I bought the yarn during NYC's yarn crawl. As the end was in sight for my holiday knitting, my dear beloved godson evidently asked Santa for a scarf. A child in CALIFORNIA ask for a scarf at the end of November. After the hats for his mom and dad were finished and his fish hat was cast on and short rows being conquered... I love him so much there is a scarf in progress now being cursed at daily on the subway.
Posted by: Ivan at December 1, 2011 4:03 PMI just read my husband your letter. His response was, "I wouldn't even know where to start." I told him that you would guide him. No pressure by the way....
Posted by: Bev S. at December 1, 2011 4:11 PMBrilliant post! :)
I am indeed knitting like crazy for the holidays. Two pairs of socks are complete, two more on the needles, and a possible fifth pair waiting in the wings which is currently a potential, planned pair of socks rather than existing in any real sense.
I had an idea for Christmas this year that I thought I'd share, as you are also a knitter and thus might also think that this is cute and fun. I am knitting socks for my Mum, Dad and sister, because they are my three favourite people in the world and because they are all knitworthy and like getting socks. (The other pair on the needles is for the husband, and is a surprise. The potential fifth pair is for the sister's girlfriend, who I haven't met yet but want to welcome into the family properly, with socks.)
About halfway through the second pair (my Mum's pair) I had a brainwave. I am going to turn my handknit socks into tiny, handknit stockings! I'll take one of the socks and roll it up, and stuff it in the other. Then I will fill the sock up with tiny, hand-picked goodies that the recipient will enjoy, so that it is like a little stocking. And then on Christmas Eve I will sneak down in the night and leave each tiny stocking next to the Christmas tree, with a little label stating who it is for. A stocking that, once you've finished emptying it of all the fun goodies, magically turns into a pair of warm, handknit socks you can wear!
I am faintly proud of myself and think maybe I am a genius. :)
Posted by: Liz at December 1, 2011 4:12 PMBravo, Sheila!
I've had a couple of yarn "Incidents" lately with cashmere-ish yarns for the baby I'm expecting in February! Tiny baby garment knitting interspersed with hats, gloves, and socks for the Christmas gifts for non tiny people!
Posted by: Andrea in Kansas at December 1, 2011 4:13 PMStellar community service, my dear.
Brillant! Classic! Spot on! I love this post and can't wait for the rest of them. "Some assembly required" is perfect. I am also a quilter, sewer, needlepointer (? sounds like a kind of dog),...basicaly any kind of fiber artist/craftsperso, so this applies to me on many levels. Thank you.
Posted by: Noralee at December 1, 2011 4:19 PMAhhh, you hit the nail on the head, as always. When those around me hear that I am knitting 12 teacher gifts, they either laugh or wonder why I bother. Hell, I posted on a Ravelry forum asking for ideas and pretty much was told it wasn't worth knitting for teachers.
But it isn't about the reaction I get, because like you say, I am knitting in gratitude. I expect that the teachers, para educators, and bus drivers keep my kids safe. But more than that, when they nurture my child, know them by name, sidle up to me and say "Wow, E. is so amazing, I adore that kid". Well, they need knitted goods. They just do.
Posted by: Christie at December 1, 2011 4:20 PMBeing a knitter married to a gun enthusiast, I have a suggestion directly from the source of all things sneaky when needing to import more fiber into the house. Put items for a project into several bags from different stores. Keep project items in trunk of car. Bring pieces in one at a time over a period of days or weeks depending on observation level of others in household. When asked if you are starting something new, is that more of, now what is it...your standard response should be, "Oh this? I just needed this to finish up a project. Nothing new here." Worked on me for 20 years...
Posted by: freda at December 1, 2011 4:29 PMThe best present my family can give me is to NOT wait until Dec. 23rd to tell me what they'd like me to knit/crochet them for Christmas. That might just lead to homicide.
Posted by: Maureen at December 1, 2011 4:39 PMSooo true. We can never get enough yarn for sure. Loved the story.
Posted by: Rowena at December 1, 2011 4:45 PMI'm posting links to this post all over my social network. This is brilliant.
ps: That doesn't look like an accident; it looks like a welcome happenstance.
pps: Actually; you're a saint for rescuing those poor lost and lonely skeins from sitting on a shelf. Now they can be loved and petted and join a stash-family and eventually become something wonderful.
Posted by: Beki at December 1, 2011 4:49 PMI had a stroke last year, and it REALLY put the brakes on my knitting. It takes me 5 x longer! So knit while you can, and nonknitters, you need to sound delighted!
Posted by: Bets at December 1, 2011 4:50 PMThis is wonderful!
I laughed, I cried (yarn accidents are awful) and being a knitting smartarse I forwarded this post to both parents, and multiple aunts and uncles - all of whom have made special requests for knitted gifts this year!
Love this! Forwarding this to my family and friends :-)
And really there can never be enough yarn... ever!
Posted by: Barbra at December 1, 2011 5:01 PMI heart you!
Posted by: Natalie B at December 1, 2011 5:15 PMJust forwarded this to my inlaws and my husband. He at least likes my knitted socks, so there is hope. A few more posts and maybe I get the right christmas gift? Anyway I love him....
Posted by: Birgitta at December 1, 2011 5:21 PMI absolutely LOVE this post! I forwarded to all of my loved ones so that they better understand (and see why I get a kick out of reading your blog posts). Since I am knitting a few almost a half dozen gifts this Christmas, it would do well for those people to read this.
Posted by: Seagoat at December 1, 2011 5:44 PMThank you! After I stopped laughing I printed this out and left it on my husband's chair for him to find when he comes home tonight.
Posted by: Ellen at December 1, 2011 5:48 PMSo let me get this right. . . in the midst of aforementioned holiday knitting frenzy, you have now committed to us - your faithful readers - that you will be blogging every day for the next 24 days?
Posted by: Charlene at December 1, 2011 5:51 PMWonderful post!!! Laughed til I cried.
Posted by: melissa at December 1, 2011 5:57 PMI am a lucky person--my lys keeps a file box at the check out with all of our "wish lists" in it by name. So I just send the various shoppers there and say, "Consult the list. If it is on the list, you are safe". They sometimes mess up and get creative on me (I cannot for love or money wear pale yellow anything) but mostly just meekly go in and see what weird thing I am wanting this year. Of course, cashmere has been on the list since the store opened...not crossed off yet. Maybe creating a wish list for the special shoppers and pinning it to Steph's blog on the frig would help?
Posted by: JodyO at December 1, 2011 6:40 PMThere is nothing I like more than spending someone else's money (read:GiftCertificate) at a yarn shop. Non-knitters should know that this can be a circular economy...as most times someone gives me this present, I go on to spend it on yarn to knit FOR person who bought the GC in the first place!
Posted by: Sara in Key West at December 1, 2011 6:40 PMLove this - hubby will be clued in to watch for the next few weeks. I especially like the tag "just because it's hand made, doesn't mean it's cheap."
Thank you!
Thank you for understanding me. I think I'll be giving this link to everyone who might be buying me Christmas presents.
Posted by: Cecilia at December 1, 2011 6:44 PM{nodding head whilst holding sides}
Trying to figure out how to get everyone I know to read this...especially certain in-laws who routinely gift horrid, cheap, mass-produced sweaters--always in size 3X -- especially annoying since I wear M or L. Grrrrrrrr
Just a minute. About hitting the 1980s layer in the pursuit of archaeology. Aren't we frequently talking to male persons here? Who has ever known a male non-knitter who understood "bulky" or "mohair". Many men I know would quiver at "mint green". Mint is a candy; green is not blue, right?
New version: if you find fuzzy green fat string, back up at least two layers.
It's exactly what your whole post says: know your audience.
Thanks for the laugh. (And Hilary, you're right: unique cannot be qualified. Neither can perfect.)
Posted by: amaryllis at December 1, 2011 6:48 PMI am soooo going to post a link to this on my fb page and tag everyone of my kids! :D
Posted by: TracyGP at December 1, 2011 7:09 PMPassing along your blog address to my Mom - who is a non knitter, but may need to shop for her favorite knitter (me)!
Posted by: Bobbie in AK at December 1, 2011 7:38 PMyou crack me up!
Posted by: Gina at December 1, 2011 7:46 PMYou are performing a priceless public service. All knitters salute you.
Posted by: Ann in the UP at December 1, 2011 7:58 PMSpot on! I'm sending this to my husband as an affirmation of what he already knows (but seems to forget at gift time). Case in point: A few weeks ago I told him I needed the car to take some baby hats to my LYS for a charity event. When I got back he asked, "So, what did you buy?" My reply: "I was just dropping off those baby hats!" "And what's in your bag now?" he responded. Ooh, just two skeins of the most beautiful yarn ever, of course!
Posted by: JennG at December 1, 2011 7:58 PMAnd if the knitter is also a kindergarten teacher . . . feel sorry for the husband!
Posted by: Lynne at December 1, 2011 8:00 PMI love you. Seriously, I love you:)
Posted by: Kate at December 1, 2011 8:03 PMGreat ideas. I'm looking forward to the rest.
Don't forget the spinners. I wonder if I dare ask for hand carders. I'll have to research exactly which ones I should ask for.
I got myself a gift today. Yup. Cortisone, right shoulder. So I can finish the Aran sweater I'm knitting for a Christmas gift.
You won't think it's weird.
Posted by: beadslut at December 1, 2011 8:13 PMI knit beautifully (if I do say so myself) but I am sometimes disappointed with my blocking. I use wires but my edges don't look as great as yours do on the Fernfrost. If you ever have time, would you mind telling us about blocking?
Posted by: Janet A at December 1, 2011 8:22 PMI am a non-knitter who loves a knitter. From all of us to you, madam, let me say thank you for these wonderful (and highly practical) gift ideas (and the ones to come). I also promise to work the phrase, "Holy mittens!" into conversation with my wife at least once a day from here on out.
Posted by: David S at December 1, 2011 8:55 PMMy older son, many years ago, spent his allowance buying me a large skein of bright red Christmas yarn with silver sparkles in it because he knew that I loved to knit. I think he may have been about eight years old at the time. I made myself a Christmas hat of the style favoured, we are told, by elves; and wore it every winter. His little face lit up every time I wore it, and in winter in rural Manitoba who cares a hoot about style? It was warm, and given to me with love and thoughtfulness, and who could want a better present than that?
Posted by: StrongCat at December 1, 2011 9:26 PMOh, you are so right! I work in a yarn shop, and at present, business is booming! The scarf knitters are out in droves, clamoring for the very latest ( and fastest ) in scarf knitting. Quick knits like Link and Flounce are flying off the shelves; I have customers who come in with lists! My own knitting is suffering, however. I can barely manage a few rows of my Grandaughter's Christmas stocking!
Posted by: Debra at December 1, 2011 9:28 PMThank you for making me feel so very not alone as I knit my 3rd Lopi tote this week. There's been some weeping and my hands are feeling funny. Of course that may be from the scarf and the socks. I don't know. It's all a blur.
Posted by: suburbancorrespondent at December 1, 2011 9:32 PMMany thanks for doing a great public service.
It took years to convince my children that a small gift certificate to the LYS was the best idea for a gift, and when two children purchased the exact same colorway of sock yarn one year, they couldn't understand my elation. Odd ducks, muggles.
Posted by: Melissa R at December 1, 2011 9:40 PMIn contrast, another knitting/gifting memory: when my youngest niece was about five years old I made her a red sweater and matching hat in the Aran idiom. Not ever so complex, but pretty and warm. I gave it as a Christmas present with pride. She ripped open the package and declared "I hate woolly things!", threw the sweater and hat on the floor, and walked away.
Posted by: StrongCat at December 1, 2011 9:43 PMThank you for buying your yarn at the end of my shift so I didn't have time to wind it.
Posted by: Denny at December 1, 2011 9:56 PMHate to disagree with Carol @ 1:37 pm, but. . .that's not an accident or a calamity. That seems to be more like The Harlot's weekly grocery list, translated to yarn!
Steph, you forgot this part of yarn archeology: If the muggle's hand hits the floor, the layer directly resting on the floor is crapcrylic from an age before the muggle was born. The muggle should leave it alone, as that crapcrylic is slowly returning to the crude oil from which it came. Hopefully to be reborn as a better grade of synthetic fiber a few thousand millenia from now.
Posted by: Anonymous, too at December 1, 2011 11:02 PMI laughed through the whole post! Really good! I have the Kniterella cards. I think that they are brilliant! You know what we knitters from the Great Montreal Area would love for Christmas? A visit from Yarn Harlot in 2012! ;-) No kidding ;-)
Posted by: Maryse at December 1, 2011 11:11 PMAmen and thank you. I've linked your letter to my blog. Couldn't have said it better myself!
Posted by: Sara at December 1, 2011 11:23 PMThank you Thank you.
I am sharing this with all I will get gifts from so they'll understand my mantra " All I want for Christmas is YARN, YARN,YARN"
Yarn is never more beautiful than when it is still in the skein. Got to buy lots more skeins!
Posted by: Bonnie at December 2, 2011 12:24 AMOh I foresee a colour gamp of some sort, on that floor loom... At least, that's what I'd be doing with that lovely yarn.
Great intro to this series. I am sure I will discover a few things I never even knew I wanted. If I'm lucky, my boyfriend will find them, too.
Posted by: Rhonda at December 2, 2011 1:20 AMHmmm the yarn "accident" looks a lot like the colours we used in your colour knitting class...did you get a brain worm at Port Ludlow? I think I did.
Posted by: Marianne at December 2, 2011 1:34 AMArghh, stupid iPad...sorry for the multiple comments
Posted by: Marianne at December 2, 2011 1:37 AMSurely one of the 24 coming days you will suggest this: a nice pen with a cord attached so you can fasten it to your knitting bag or chair or basket, whatever and only with some difficulty removable. Writing pads are nice, but every time I change a pattern according to my specific size while I am knitting I have to hunt for a pen, somebody (leprechaun maybe, well, that somebody who makes things get lost) took of with my pen and I give up writing down the change and well, I forget what I changed and how and next time I have to do the figuring out all over again. Or maybe there are writing pens with a "whistle and I will answer" app;-) like keychains.
I'm wondering if Hilary is an english teacher or an editor??
Posted by: KIminAK at December 2, 2011 3:23 AMI SO love this blog post! Hilarious!
Posted by: Annatalvikki at December 2, 2011 3:25 AMForgot to mention: the same goes for cardmakers, people who spent at least fifteen minutes( up to more then an hour) to make a nice Christmas/birthday/anniversarycard, searching for the right theme for that particular person, putting all their love into that card. There are also people, I am told, who buy 50 cards for five dollars in less then two minutes, just writing adresses whitout even looking at the pictures. Cardmakers love new stash too, maybe an advertisement paper of the particular shop you bought a gift card for them would make that present just a little bit more particular or add the webbadress if it is not on the card.
Posted by: dutch margreet at December 2, 2011 3:36 AMI'd like to translate this post into Russian for my blog. Can I? I know, my readers will appreciate it.
Thanks in advance.
Holy Mittens indeed ... the yarnharlot has made my day ... thanks SO much and I'll stand you a beer [or two ...] when you're next on this side of the pond
Posted by: Julie Nelson Rhodes at December 2, 2011 5:16 AMWhen it comes to the spinner in your life, there really is no better gift than the Fiber Binder Club from Dyed in the Wool.biz. Every month, a new natural fiber to try out.
Posted by: Benita at December 2, 2011 6:52 AMI just learned to knit this year (at the grand old age of 45) and got 2 knitting boks today (birthday girl!). I'd just like to thank you all for everything I've learned from this post and its comments, particularly the excellent method of smuggling new stash additions into the house. I shall be practising this a LOT.
Posted by: Jane at December 2, 2011 7:14 AMI'm going to have to embellish on your "yarn accident" But honey "I fell into a Yarn Store and had a yarn accident"
Posted by: Jennifer at December 2, 2011 7:26 AMAhh, you make me have knitterly smiles,..wishing you Happy Knitting and fruitful yarn accidents for the coming year.
Posted by: Amy at December 2, 2011 7:31 AMHilary -- And yet some would say that in a contest between usage and civility, civility should win.
Posted by: rams at December 2, 2011 8:01 AMI so adore this post!! I'm going to send it to my fiance in hopes that hearing this same idea from another person will make me seem less crazy. And GREAT knitter gift ideas!!
Posted by: Kat at December 2, 2011 8:07 AMI read you, but I think I have only commented once. This though? I've just sent this to my family and friends. Perfecto.
Posted by: abby at December 2, 2011 8:29 AMHaha! This all sounds very familiar, I'll send it to my boyf. as fair warning.
Posted by: Jenny at December 2, 2011 8:51 AMWho reads a post and corrects grammar and spelling? Wow.
Anywayyyy... love the post - Fernfrost is so beautiful that I bought the pattern and intend to cast on right after Christmas. Thanks Stephanie!
Posted by: Rebecca at December 2, 2011 8:52 AMJust what I needed. thanks for the pick me up.
Posted by: kmessier27 at December 2, 2011 9:46 AMYou should have endorsment deal- and a brand.
Posted by: Heather at December 2, 2011 9:53 AMBloody brilliant! I am sending this link to my husband who just last night said "I don't want to get you more knitting stuff because you already have that."
I can't wait to read more!
Posted by: Elizabeth at December 2, 2011 10:15 AMThat 'accident' photo looks surprisingly similar to the one I had two weeks ago.
Posted by: Wen at December 2, 2011 10:16 AMAny Canadian suppliers for knitting gifts? I like to shop locally if possible.
Posted by: Julie at December 2, 2011 10:17 AMThe Kniterella gift tags are some of my favorites...I bought some this summer, and can't wait to crack them out for Christmas!
Posted by: Allison at December 2, 2011 10:26 AMI bought my own knitting present this year. I made a list. My husband looked at it, shrugged and handed me cash (I was already half way through the online checkout.)
It should arrive soon, but he won't let me touch any of it (even to give it a loving squeeze) until after Christmas *sigh*
Posted by: eberndl at December 2, 2011 10:26 AMRIGHT ON!
Posted by: Lee Bernstein at December 2, 2011 10:39 AMHA! Rams, you're my hero!!
Posted by: carrie at December 2, 2011 11:15 AMDear Stephanie,
Thank you so much for the extreme, but silent laughter I'm experiencing while reading this post. I'm "LIS" (laughing inside) since I'm in a quiet workplace at the moment.
I hope to become a Knitter (just a dabbler right now) and your writings and photos have been an inspiration to me. The humor, however, may put me over the edge into a full-blown knitting life change extravaganza!
Thanks again,
Jill
someone just came to check on me to see why I was sitting alone in my office laughing !
Posted by: meredith at December 2, 2011 12:11 PMI've been sending this fantastic funny post to my husband and non-knitter friends. Also, ignore my previous request for book information. I think I found the hat in one of your old blog posts.
Posted by: Penelope at December 2, 2011 12:18 PMHrm, that yarn, it looks familiar, I mean the colours... It reminds me of that stripey baby sweater you mads. When I saw the baby version, my first thought was, I want that in my size!
So curious to find out what it's for!
Also, you are Brilliant. And I will be sending my husband here for advice. ;)
Posted by: Mielissa at December 2, 2011 12:21 PMa super post, but i kinda wish the 25 ideas were going to be divided among, say, 5 posts so i could print them out and hand them to my kids before they've finished their financially constrained shopping. one has massive college loans; the other is grandperson to 10 adorable pit bull pups who are eating like wolves.
i'd never tell them "don't buy me anything," because we all need to feel the pleasure of giving. but i sure like having options to offer them.
ah, well -- i can print out the later posts (or excerpts) and hand them copies around nov. 20 next year.
and speaking of gifts, it would be a great gift to central indiana to have a springtime visit from the yarn harlot. you will be greeted with tasty local beer and endangered species chocolate.
(hey -- there's something to add to the remaining posts: CHOCOLATE to fuel one's favorite knitter's/crocheter's efforts!)
Posted by: ellen in indy at December 2, 2011 12:44 PMAm sending your blog link to the men in my family straight away. Whether or not they have the wherewithal to read it remains to be seen. I have my doubts. And the yarn accident? Well, s*** happens.
Posted by: shelly at December 2, 2011 1:05 PMI also loved the post and read it aloud to my husband. And as to the accident/incident and how much yarn is too much...one of my brothers has a wonderful saying, "If some is good and more is better, than too much is just about right." Love reading your stuff!
Posted by: Helen at December 2, 2011 3:04 PMOk, loved the post!! I really was a fan of yours but do not have as much energy as you so have tried to stay away from your post so I could get some knitting, spinning, weaving and working done plus support our household! I am the knitting etc half of the 2=1 fan from Seattle.
Posted by: Sally O'Neill at December 2, 2011 4:33 PMWhat great gift ideas! I love them all.. and your little swatches... I like them both, but I think I like the little stained glass effect just a tad more, and I can' wait to see what it's going to be when it grows up.
Posted by: Patti at December 2, 2011 6:57 PMMy husband complains about the gnashing of the needles around the house (those are his words), but a few years back he handmade me a christmas tree ornament--a ball of red yarn, crossed with green, with two very small knitting needles sticking out of it in an X. He had to grind regular needles down in a pencil sharpener. This is how I know he still loves me.
Posted by: Jody at December 2, 2011 7:04 PMI've asked for a Nantucket Crochet Bagg (I gave my husband the link so there can be no mistake which one I want). Thirty pockets!
Posted by: Elizabeth Fry at December 2, 2011 7:05 PMYes!!! Last year my daughter not only gave me the stitch markers I asked for, but she also bought me sock yarn! I think I'll send her a link to this post...
Posted by: Gail at December 2, 2011 9:54 PM"Holy Mittens" Love it! I think that could become a catch phrase. How about "Holy Mittens, Batman!" A Priceless Post.
Posted by: Angela at December 3, 2011 8:29 AMAs the husband of a knitter. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. This holiday I just may get it right.
Posted by: Eric at December 3, 2011 11:45 AMActually, if my husband burrows deeply enough to find mint green chunky brushed mohair, he has tunneled into the wrong house, but I think he will stop when he hits concrete.
Posted by: Trish at December 3, 2011 1:33 PMLove it with the black - looks like little multicolored sheep tushies with their backs toward us. Hope it will be mittens.
Posted by: refhead at December 3, 2011 3:59 PMLove this need to forward to my husband!
Thank you!!!
What is the yarn? I can't read the label and the colour and soft appearance are killing me with envy! Also is there somewhere we can find the stitch pattern, I think it is simple and stunning appropriate for both genders. Right now the only members of my family who get knits are the girls and my Grandpa because I can whip out things that they love quite easily.
Posted by: Heather at December 5, 2011 7:37 PMThat might be this type of a terrific cleverness which will you will be delivering and you just allow the application separate designed for free of cost. As i enjoy discovering internet sites which will figure out that appeal in rendering an important superior quality power source designed for no cost. It is that out of date whatever round occurs all over regime .
Posted by: Teofila Dudik at December 6, 2011 12:11 PMWonderful goods from you, man. Yarn Harlot: For the Others I have understand your stuff previous to and you are just extremely wonderful. I really like what you've acquired here, certainly like what you're saying and the way in which you say it. You make it entertaining and you still care for to keep it sensible. I can not wait to read much more from you. This is really a tremendous Yarn Harlot: For the Others informations.
Posted by: invest liberty reserve at December 8, 2011 3:15 AMGreat goods from you, man. Yarn Harlot: For the Others I have understand your stuff previous to and you are just extremely magnificent. I actually like what you have acquired here, really like what you're stating and the way in which you say it. You make it enjoyable and you still care for to keep it smart. I cant wait to read much more from you. This is really a tremendous Yarn Harlot: For the Others informations.
Posted by: Android Apps at December 8, 2011 4:09 AMI got what you will, thanks for swing up. Woh I am glad to see this website through google. Thanks For Share Yarn Harlot: For the Others.
Posted by: LA Weight Loss at December 15, 2011 11:16 AM